I believe the Blogstorm over Eason Jordan will be a turning point for the mainstream media. No, not the point when blogs passed them in influence--that time was long ago (in Internet time).
No, this will be the moment when the mainstream media realizes it. Trent Lott, Rathergate...even as far back as Drudge breaking the Lewinsky story--was all treated by the media as isolated incidents, partisans in the middle of campaigns, and in many cases the MSM just used blogs as a tool to get a story going that otherwise they would have had to ignore. Bloggers were just another source, in their mind--less reliable, more partisan, but still outside of the media. Note that point: in their mind, bloggers are outside of the media, not just outside of the mainstream.
But this time, it really is one of their own (Rather wasn't, really, since he was from a long-ago generation) and more important, Mickey Kaus is using the story as a club to bludgeon Howard Kurtz, a guy who works for the paper that just bought Slate, and is trying to get into this crazy Internet thing in a big way.
This time the media will really realize it. And mark my words: the backlash is going to be ugly. These guys are going to be hitting blogs hard, as if they were fighting for their lives. Which they are.
Posted by David at February 10, 2005 07:27 PM | TrackBackEarlier today, I sent an e-mail to Saint Paul over at Fraters Libertas mocking him for missing a closing italics in his post and italicizing his entire site. Then, not 20 minutes later, I did the same thing in this post.
Ah, justice.
Posted by: Monkey David at February 10, 2005 09:53 PMI'm a little more cynical/pessimistic about the whole thing. I think the MSM may be able to slide past this one last time, partly because nobody who isn't a news junkie really knows who Eason Jordan is (as opposed to Dan Rather), and the story doesn't really have any salacious qualities like the Lewinsky story. So CNN may be able to "lay low" and let this blow over.
If it does, it may reenforce the MSM's misguided arrogance about their invincibility. Unfortunately, a story still doesn't become A STORY until you start seeing the mainstream outlets referring to it prominently, as they did with Rather and Lewinsky.
My rule of thumb for a news story's "critical mass" is that my wife's parents know about it. When they hear about it on the evening news and Jay Leno, then the story has become unstoppable.
More cynicism: If the MSM can get past this and one or two more scandals, they will be beyond their point of significant vulnerability. Like post-Watergate government, the general public will have grown to accept that this is "the way things are" and stories of corruption, bias, and impropriety will no longer be news.
Posted by: RobbL Monkey at February 11, 2005 08:54 AMI want David to be right, but I fear RobbL is. As a dedicated blog reader myself, I often feel the need to step back and remind myself that not everybody reads blogs. I think it might be fair to say most don't even know about them. So while we get all wound up over a story, I fear that it is just passing the general public by.
Extra Apostrophes for AnalMonkey David: ' ' ' ' ' '
Posted by: JamesPh. at February 11, 2005 03:15 PMWell, score one point for the optimists. Looks like Jordan quit. Now we'll see if the story still has legs.
Posted by: RobbL Monkey at February 11, 2005 07:08 PMI am going to have to remain pessimistic on the story still having legs. My guess is Eason was forced out by CNN or Time-Warner in order to kill the story. Other than the blogosphere, the MSM has no incentive to keep this story alive.
Posted by: JamesPh. at February 12, 2005 03:50 PMOh, I don't disagree with you, James. But my I stand by what I said: this is a turning point not because the story will continue to grow, but because it represents a wake-up call within the MSM. Expect to see more "investigations" of bloggers ahead, with the goal of discouraging bloggers...
Posted by: Monkey David at February 12, 2005 07:36 PMActually the MSM knew it with Rathergate. Look at how they and their surrogate Columbia attacked blogs in Nov and Dec last year. After their coverup of Eason failed last month everyone knows. IT can not get much uglier than it was a month ago.
Posted by: Rod Stanton at February 26, 2005 05:20 PM