Building a Bar

Imbibe magazine's current issue has an article about building a home bar (not the carpentry, or even how to organize it, just what to have). It's in pieces on the web, such as this section on what booze to stock.

It's not a bad article, but I'd question the basic philosophy. I have to agree with someone I read (maybe Ben could help me remember) who said the way to build a bar is pick a basic cocktail, such as martini or margarita, get the ingredients, and then experiment with making it with different recipes until you perfect how you'd like it. I'd go even further, and say that if it's in your means, get a few different brands of the ingredients, and see how different gins or tequilas can be (vodkas less so, at least in mixed drinks, and whiskeys perhaps most of all).

But it did get me to thinking...what are the essentials that you would need to have in order to say you have a respectable home bar? I'm just going to focus on the booze this time, not the equipment or mixers or garnishes. Stripped down to basics, and with an eye for economy (which knocks out, say, Junipero or Old Potrero) what would you need? I'd argue the following:

Brandy Lairds Applejack
Brandy Landy VSOP Cognac
Gin Plymouth
Liqueur Cointreau
Liqueur Kahlua
Liqueur Maraska Maraschino
Rum Cruzan (Light)
Rum Myers (Dark)
Tequila Milagro (silver--I don't consider reposado essential, though others might)
Vermouth Noilly Prat (Dry)
Vermouth Vya (Sweet)
Apéritif Lillet
Vodka Skyy
Whiskey Jameson (Irish)
Whisky Johnny Walker Black (Scotch)
Whiskey Woodford Reserve (Bourbon)
Whiskey Old Overholt (Rye)

It was tough to leave out some things, especially Campari and cachaça, but choices had to be made...I welcome suggestions, though, and cries of outrage at my choices.

Trackback URL for this post:

http://blog.infinitemonkeysblog.com/?q=trackback/6412

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Re: Building a bar

This is a tough one, especially when it comes to picking essential liqueurs. One addition you must, must, must have is orange Curaçao, which is not the same as a triple sec (such as Cointreau) and is a vital ingredient in a proper mai tai.

Otherwise, this is a very good list. I can't think of anything else I would add, apart from the two you mentioned that you left out.

A few additions

I agree with the above poster, you need another orange liqueur, but one of the darker ones that's made with brandy or Cognac rather than a clear spirit like Cointreau. Gran Gala is awesome and much cheaper than Gran Marinier.

Otherwise, you've got an awesome selection there, but I've got to ask... where are the bitters? I've got ten different bottles I keep in a little box, they don't take up much room but can really make or break a cocktail.

Bitters

Bitters, of course, are indispensable. We're big on bitters around here. David has at least 10 bitters bottles behind his bar. I'm about due for a resupply. But, as I'm sure you know, there's a difference between "potable" and "non-potable" bitters. Potable bitters would be degestifs such as Campari or Amer Picon. Non-potable bitters are Angostura and Fee Bros. That's probably why David left them off the list. Great suggestion, though. A Manhattan without bitters is like pizza without sauce. Cheers!

Agreed!

Even though I'm a fan of Campari, Pastis, and some other aperitifs, I was referring to the potent flavor enhancers. I've got Angostura, Peychaud's, and eight different varieties of Fee's. Recently I tried each of them using the same Manhattan recipe (Maker's Mark, Noilly Prat Sweet Red Vermouth, and a cherry):

http://wine-by-benito.blogspot.com/2009/04/news-manhattan-project.html

How about bar tools? Zesters and shakers and strainers, oh my!

Bitters

Oh, yes, I love the bitters. I was trying to stick to just the booze, though. I do plan on further posts on the other bar essentials, but I'm not sure what to say about bitters. Agostura and Peychaud's are essential, of course, and I love the Fee's bitters, but I'm not sure which one is essential. I think I prefer Regan's Orange Bitters to Fee's, although I had an unpleasant experience with a bottle tasting weird...I think it was bad storage (on my part) rather than bottle variation, but it...well, left a bad taste in my mouth. (Literally, Ben.) I supposed an orange bitters is also essential, but I'm not sure.
On another note, Benito, it's funny how small the world of booze is...your post that you linked to in your comment mentions Samantha Dugan, from whom I buy most of my champagne and wine (at Wine Country, in Signal Hill, near Long Beach). Most of my booze comes from Hi-Time, though, since it's so very cheap there.
Also, since I'm plugging places, one of the most wonderful places on the planet is Bar Keeper in Silverlake. It deserves its own post, and I'm feeling guilty I haven't done that yet, but I'll just say here that he has just about every kind of bitters on the market, and will let you sample them in the store (diluted, of course, and that's all I'll say here). He also has an amazing selection of bar tools and glasses, both vintage and new.

[mclaughlin] WRONG! [/mclaughlin]

I've gotta take issue with the Jameson recommendation. Powers Gold Label is miles better, and usually less expensive (most liquor stores have it for around $20.) Jameson's 12-year whiskey is quite good, but the standard stuff just doesn't do it.

(That said, if you're in a typical grocery store where your only choices are basic Jameson and Bushmills, definitely go with the Jameson.)

((Then again, if you're stocking a respectable bar, what in the world are you doing in a typical grocery store?))

One more addition

Bailey's Irish Cream. A must in my opinion. Or, perhaps you choose to keep it next to the coffee pot instead of in the bar area.